meals and food
  • HOME
  • RECIPES
    • APPETIZERS
    • BEVERAGES
    • BREAKFAST
    • CASSEROLES
    • COOKIES
    • SEAFOOD
    • COPYCAT RECIPES
    • SIDE DISH
    • SOUP
  • Dinner
  • MEALS
  • DESSERTS
  • HOME
  • RECIPES
    • APPETIZERS
    • BEVERAGES
    • BREAKFAST
    • CASSEROLES
    • COOKIES
    • SEAFOOD
    • COPYCAT RECIPES
    • SIDE DISH
    • SOUP
  • Dinner
  • MEALS
  • DESSERTS
No Result
View All Result
meals and food
No Result
View All Result
Home RECIPES

Easy Red Robin Mud Pie Copycat Recipe That Tastes Just Right

by wsg1001
10/07/2025
in RECIPES
478 15
0
Easy Red Robin Mud Pie Copycat Recipe That Tastes Just Right
739
SHARES
3.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

My Messy Kitchen Adventure

Woke up yesterday craving something stupidly chocolatey. Remembered that bomb Red Robin mud pie, but ain’t no way I’m driving over there just for dessert. Figured, how hard could a copycat be? Found a recipe online claiming to be “easy,” laughed nervously, and dove straight in.

Easy Red Robin Mud Pie Copycat Recipe That Tastes Just Right

Step one: Gathering the stuff. Ransacked my pantry first. Found a sleeve of Oreos – score! Needed some instant coffee granules for that deep flavor. Had to run to the corner store ’cause my milk was sour. Grabbed the biggest tub of vanilla ice cream they had. Coffee granules were near impossible to find, spent like 10 minutes squinting at labels. Got chocolate sauce and caramel stuff too, obviously.

The Crust Chaos

Okay, time to make a mess. Threw like 20 Oreos into a ziploc bag. Whacked ’em with my rolling pin. Smashed ’em up real good, but ended up with some big chunks still. Whatever. Melted a chunk of butter – kinda guessed the amount? Mixed the buttery mess into the cookie crumbs with a fork. Pressed that into a pie pan with my fingers. Tried getting it up the sides but it kept crumbling down. Got frustrated, shoved it in the freezer and slammed the door.

Ice Cream Insanity

Let that crust chill for maybe 15 minutes. Didn’t have much patience. Pulled the ice cream tub out. That stuff was rock solid. Digged at it with a spoon while cussing under my breath. Finally hacked off chunks into a big mixing bowl. Left it sitting out for like 20 minutes to soften up a bit. Stirred it around, added a spoonful of coffee granules. Tried dissolving them first in a drop of hot water – felt like a pro chef move for a second. Mixed it all until it looked kinda like muddy ice cream.

Assembly Line Disaster

Pulled the crust pan out. Spooned half the coffee ice cream sludge into it. Smoothed it out kinda. Then, disaster. Opened the chocolate sauce and it exploded onto my hand. Wiped it on my jeans. Drizzled some sauce over the ice cream layer. Same thing with the caramel – it just globbed out. Tried making a cool pattern, failed miserably. Dropped the rest of the ice cream sludge on top. Almost overflowed the pan. Shoved it back into the freezer. Prayed.

The Long Wait… And Taste Test

Left it in there for a solid 4 hours. Watched dumb videos to kill time. Finally pulled it out. Topped it with whipped cream from a can straight outta the fridge. Made a nice little mountain. Sprinkled leftover cookie crumbs on top because, why not? Sliced a piece. Looked like dog food honestly. But holy hell, that first bite? Chills. Dense coffee chocolate ice cream, the crunchy crust, the sticky sauces? Freaking nailed it! Tasted crazy close to Red Robin. Messy kitchen was totally worth it. Garbage bags full of dirty dishes though. Not looking forward to that.

Previous Post

Cookies With Santa Plate Storage Guide Keep Your Treats Fresh Longer

Next Post

Where is OBX Seafood Festival located? Map directions and parking advice.

wsg1001

wsg1001

Next Post
Where is OBX Seafood Festival located? Map directions and parking advice.

Where is OBX Seafood Festival located? Map directions and parking advice.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Popular

    Navigate

    • Home
    • Archives

    Recent Recipes

    Ocean City Maryland Seafood Buffet Secrets: Hidden Gems for Amazing Food!

    Ocean City Maryland Seafood Buffet Secrets: Hidden Gems for Amazing Food!

    10/07/2025
    How to Bake Perfect Cookies with Sprinkles (Easy Step-by-Step Guide)

    How to Bake Perfect Cookies with Sprinkles (Easy Step-by-Step Guide)

    10/07/2025

    Browse by Category

    • APPETIZERS
    • BEVERAGES
    • BREAKFAST
    • CASSEROLES
    • COOKIES
    • COPYCAT RECIPES
    • DESSERTS
    • Dinner
    • MEALS
    • RECIPES
    • SEAFOOD
    • SIDE DISH
    • SOUP

    Browse by Ingredients

    Bakery Brunch Cafe Cake Chicken Coffee Gluten Free Mint Raspberry Red Pepper Rice Vegan

    © 2025 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • HOME
    • RECIPES
      • APPETIZERS
      • BEVERAGES
      • BREAKFAST
      • CASSEROLES
      • COOKIES
      • SEAFOOD
      • COPYCAT RECIPES
      • SIDE DISH
      • SOUP
    • Dinner
    • MEALS
    • DESSERTS

    © 2025 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password?

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In