Okay, here’s my take on sharing my “hotel arlington chicken salad recipe” experience in a blog post format.

My Attempt at the Hotel Arlington Chicken Salad: A Kitchen Adventure
Alright, folks, let me tell you about my latest kitchen experiment: tackling the famous Hotel Arlington Chicken Salad recipe. I saw it floating around online, and being a sucker for a good chicken salad, I figured, “Why not?” Let me just say, it was a journey.
First things first, I went shopping. The recipe called for cooked chicken (duh!), celery, grapes, pecans, mayo, and some seasonings. I grabbed a rotisserie chicken to save time. I’m all about shortcuts when they make sense. Got home, wrestled the chicken apart (still kinda warm – yikes!), and started chopping.
The recipe I found didn’t give super exact measurements, which is kinda annoying. So I just winged it, which is my usual style, honestly. I chopped the celery pretty fine, because nobody wants big, crunchy chunks of celery overpowering everything. The grapes I halved – red ones, because they looked prettier. And the pecans? I toasted them in a pan for a few minutes to bring out that nutty flavor. Don’t skip that step; it makes a difference!
Now, the mayo. This is where things got interesting. The recipe just said “mayonnaise.” Okay, cool. But what kind? I went with my favorite full-fat kind – I’m not messing around with low-fat mayo in my chicken salad. I started with what I thought was a reasonable amount, mixed everything together… and it was dry. Seriously dry. So I added more mayo. Then a little more. It’s a fine line between “creamy” and “mayo soup,” you know?
- Pro-Tip: Add the mayo a little at a time! Seriously, learn from my mistakes.
Seasoning-wise, I went with salt, pepper, and a little bit of garlic powder. I considered adding a touch of Dijon mustard, but decided to keep it simple this time. I mixed everything together, gave it a taste, and… it was okay. Not amazing, but okay.
I felt like it was missing something. It needed some zip. So, I grabbed a lemon and squeezed in a little juice. BOOM! That was it. The lemon brightened everything up and balanced out the richness of the mayo.
I piled it onto some croissants and ate it for lunch. Honestly? It was pretty good! Not sure if it’s exactly like the Hotel Arlington’s version, but I enjoyed it. The chicken was tender, the celery and grapes added crunch and sweetness, and the pecans gave it that nutty flavor. The lemon was the real MVP. I will definitely be making this again. Next time, I might try adding some chopped apples or maybe even a little curry powder for a twist.

All in all, it was a fun little cooking adventure. Messy, a little stressful with the mayo situation, but ultimately, worth it. Give it a try yourself and let me know what you think!