Alright, so the other day, I got this massive craving for a good shrimp cocktail, not just any shrimp cocktail, but something with a bit of a kick, you know? Something like what you’d get in Cartagena. So, I decided, why not just make it myself? It’s not rocket science, after all.

Getting the Shrimp Ready
First things first, the shrimp. I got about a pound of decent-sized ones, shell-on, because they just taste better that way. Some folks like to steam ’em, and they say it’s gentler. Sure, maybe. But I went with boiling. Why? Because I like to get some flavor into the water, and that flavor goes right into the shrimp.
So, I got a pot of water going, threw in a bay leaf, some peppercorns, a wedge of lemon, and a good pinch of salt. Once it was boiling like crazy, I dumped the shrimp in. You gotta watch ’em close, though. They cook super fast. We’re talking maybe 2-3 minutes, just until they’re pink and curled up. Any longer and they get rubbery, and nobody wants that.
As soon as they were done, I fished ’em out and plunged them straight into an ice bath. Stops the cooking right in its tracks and makes ’em nice and cool. Once they were chilled, I peeled and deveined them. A bit fiddly, but hey, good food takes a little effort.
Whipping Up That Sauce
Now, for the star of the show, apart from the shrimp, of course – the sauce. This is where you can really make it your own. I started with a good base. Here’s what I chucked into a bowl:
- Mayonnaise, a good dollop of it. Not too much, not too little.
- Ketchup. Yeah, ketchup. Some people use fancy tomato chutney, but good old ketchup works wonders and gives it that classic vibe.
- A splash of Worcestershire sauce. You can’t skip this; it adds that “oomph.”
- A tiny bit of horseradish. I like it with a bit of a sinus-clearing kick, but you gotta be careful not to overdo it.
- A few dashes of hot sauce. Tabasco is classic, but use whatever you fancy.
Then, I squeezed in some fresh lemon juice – really brightens it up. Salt and freshly cracked black pepper, to taste, obviously. Gave it all a real good mix until it was smooth and perfectly pink. I tasted it, adjusted a bit here and there. You know how it is, a little more lemon, a touch more hot sauce, until it’s just right.
Putting It All Together
With the shrimp chilled and the sauce tasting like a winner, it was time to assemble. I like to keep it simple. Some people add chopped celery or onions, but I wanted the shrimp and sauce to be the main event.
So, I just took my lovely, plump shrimp and gave them a gentle toss in that delicious sauce. Not drowning them, mind you, just enough to coat them nicely. I like to see the shrimp, not just a bowl of sauce.

I spooned the mixture into a couple of chilled glasses. Makes it look a bit fancy, doesn’t it? For a final touch, I dusted the top with a tiny bit of paprika – mostly for color, if I’m being honest – and sprinkled over some finely chopped chives. Looks good, tastes good.
Served it up right away with a lemon wedge on the side. Man, it hit the spot. Cool, tangy, a little spicy, with those perfectly cooked shrimp. Way better than anything you’d buy pre-made. And honestly, it was pretty easy. Give it a go!